BiblioAddict


The Death of Reading!
July 15, 2007, 5:14 pm
Filed under: Books

It seems as if every week there’s a new scary article about how people just aren’t reading as much as they used to in the glory days (case in point: this one, though it is wittily funny).  Don’t ask this reader when these supposed “glory days” were since she has absolutely no idea. What she does know is that she’s read so many articles announcing the imminent funeral and wake of reading that she’s likely to explode with annoyance and frustration.

Don’t get me wrong, I care as much about reading (or, rather, the lack thereof in contemporary society) as much as the next bibliophile, but these panicked articles coming from the publishers, and the critics, and the librarians, and the teachers, and whoever else decides to poll and study our reading habits is beginning to smack of literary fear-mongering.

It annoys me that, as if I don’t have enough to be worried about – Is the man knocking on my door at 3 am in dire need of help or is he a sociopathic killer? Is today the day the terrorists bomb the D.C. subway on my way to work? – I’m also now supposed be to worried if my neighbor will read at least one novel this year that doesn’t star a certain Harry Potter and isn’t on the bestseller list.

Again, don’t get me wrong. The fact that people don’t read as much as they probably should is a big cultural problem. But, enough already! Yes, reading is dying, but what are we doing about it? It no longer scares me that reading is declining. What scares me is that for all of this talk about the death of culture and informed criticism, there doesn’t seem to be very much action to combat this downward spiral. If there is, this reader certainly isn’t hearing about it.

And according to all of the literary undertakers populating the papers today, if something isn’t done soon, we may all find ourselves faced with this horrific scene:

It is a dark and lonely night sometime in the near future. You find yourself walking down a deserted street when suddenly out of the darkness and fog emerges the tall, dark figure of a man, headed in your direction. As his face hits the streetlights you see that his sharp features bear the menacing stamp of a serial killer: his eyes are sunken, his hair stands on end, and his mouth looks as if it’s on the verge of a threatening grimace. His large body is cloaked in a black trench coat and his hands are thrust into its bulging pockets; it doesn’t take much for you to imagine a small knife or gun gripped in his sweaty hidden palms.

Nervously, you clutch the small can of mace in your own pocket, prepared to spray with vengeance if necessary. All too soon, you find yourself within five feet of this potential murderer. Suddenly, his glittering eyes alight on your face, and your heart stops beating. You grip the can of mace harder and your voice catches in your throat when, without warning, as he passes, the man grabs you with one hand and shoves something in your face with the other.

Fear and panic clutches your stomach, but before you remember your mace you recognize the object he’s waving in your face – a small paperback. It isn’t until he says, “So…what about that new James Patterson?” that you begin to scream. You kick the horrible man in the shins, spray him in his surprised eyes and make your escape. As you run away from the terrible man and his horrific literature, you hear him stumble to his feet and inquire with bloodcurdling curiosity: “Ah! What did you think of the last Harry Potter? Miss! What about that Harry Potter?”

Oh, the horror! The horror!


14 Comments so far
Leave a comment

lmao

this is absolutely hilarious- hear, hear!

Comment by Eva

I don’t believe that reading is dying. It’s always been the case that a small minority of the population reads a lot and the rest don’t. That there’s a conspiracy to cause reading folk anxiety because they ought to get off their backsides and do something ‘more useful’ with their time, now that I might believe!

Comment by litlove

Eva, you thought it was funny? It gave me the shivers even as I was writing it. ;)

litlove, it seems as if everywhere I look there’s always something else to be afraid of. The list just gets longer and longer; it’s annoying that this “culture of fear” is intruding upon my reading life as well. Number 1 on my TBR reading list:
The Culture of Fear
by Barry Glassner.

Comment by J.S. Peyton

I am not aware of the glory days either. I always read more than my friends. I think people read as much as they always have, but that is just me.

Comment by Kelly

These sort of concerns about reading always leave me a bit perplexed. I teach high school, and do you know what 90% of the students do when they finish a test that others are still working on? They pull out a novel. And these are not all just assigned novels for English class. Young people are reading a wider variety of genres than were available to kids in the past: anime, fantasy, sci-fi, literary fiction, graphic novels, chick lit, mysteries, etc. My kids both read. Their friends read. There’s always a waiting list for new fiction at the library. Bookstores are the new hip meat market on Friday and Saturday nights. And all these people using the internet? That’s reading. And so what if your neighbor DOES read only best-sellers? Those are books, right? If anything, MORE people read than did in the past, because more people know HOW to read, since our kids aren’t being pulled out of school after second grade to help on the farm any more.

Comment by Dew

Amen!!!

Comment by LK

NO! NO! How am I supposed to sleep tonight with that pop literature marauder on the loose?

Don’t you come near me with your Tom Clancy or your John Grisham! I’ve got Jim Crace and I know how to use him.

Comment by kookiejar

Kelly, I’m inclined to agree. But maybe that’s why we have so many articles and statistics on reading lately – to convince us doubters that we really have reached the end of reading days. For all their yelling, I’m still not fully convinced.

Dew, you’re preaching to the choir. I’m a little unsure if you’re yelling at me or at the literary fear-mongers, so maybe I should clarify my position a bit: I too am always a bit perplexed by the articles and stats on people not reading – how and where they get those numbers is always a bit too obscure for me. I see people reading all the time: on the bus, on the subway, standing in line…to me they’re everywhere! But I try to give some of those articles the benefit of the doubt because despite what I see now, I recall the days when I grew up. In high school, I wasn’t known as the girl who read a lot, I was known as the girl who read. Suffice it to say, that in my school, when the kids in my class finished a test, they didn’t pull out a book – they doodled in their notebook. I don’t offer that as proof that all the statistics are right. But before I dismiss them out of hand because of where I find myself now (surrounded by literate people who seem to appreciate reading as much as I do) I think of where I was then and think that perhaps the stats aren’t all wrong either. In all honesty, I haven’t made up my mind either way. The problem I have is that, if declining readership is a problem, I’d like the critics and whoever else to shut up about it and do something. To me, that’s like a man standing outside yelling, “My house is burning! My house is burning!” while he has a bucket in his hand…

Comment by J.S. Peyton

I think even if people are only reading what Oprah tells them to, or the seemingly monthly releases by James Patterson, at least they’re reading something, you know? With every Tom Clancy someone reads, they’re that much closer to moving on to something better (hopefully). Books, music, movies – I started off enjoying utter crap in all of them before my tastes started to evolve.

Comment by Calum

…and (sorry for the long comment) please don’t think I have a problem with people reading bestsellers or Harry Potter. I’m a “to each his own kind of gal.” I read many things that the literary snobs would call “trash” so I wouldn’t even begin to throw stones in that glass house. My comments above about the neighbor who reads Harry Potter or bestsellers, as well as the story that follows, was a facetious (perhaps ineffective?) poke at namely the article I linked to above. That article and many others like it seem to suggest that the popularity of books like Harry Potter and those by Patterson (neither of which, I’ve read)is just as scary as a population who supposedly doesn’t read. “Literature,” that is. Whatever that is.

Comment by J.S. Peyton

kookiejar – Oh he’s coming for you. He’s the new literary boogey-man, and he’s bringing his pal, “Shakespeare Who?” too. Now that guy’s very scary. ;)

Calum, I too started out in very humble reading beginnings. I’ve always loved to read, but it wasn’t until high school that I realized that writing could be more than just functional: it could be lyrical and beautiful and surprising. Whatever people’s tastes in literature and wherever they begin, I’d wish for everyone to have the chance to experience that kind of writing.

Comment by J.S. Peyton

Great post. I think that “fear” is mostly from the publishers. It might be more true to say that it’s much harder to make money from books these day. That’s what I believe is really going on in the background.

Comment by 3m

Sorry :(

Comment by Anastassios

3m, I too think that the “fear” is much more market driven than many folks would have you believe.

Anastassios, apology accepted (though, I will require your right arm, and your first-born child.) But first, why are you apologizing again?

Comment by J.S. Peyton




Leave a comment
Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <pre> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>